The Boroughs on Netflix review: if you like Stranger Things, you should watch The Boroughs

The Boroughs is a very easy sell if your favorite part of Stranger Things was never just the bikes-and-80s nostalgia. If what you really loved was the mystery, the misfit-team chemistry, the creeping sense that something is deeply wrong in this town, and the feeling that the show actually wants you to keep digging, then this is in your lane.

Our MyMovieJam verdict is simple: we recommend it without hesitation. The score is 8/10. The pitch is even simpler: if you like Stranger Things, you should watch The Boroughs. It hits the same curiosity button, but with an older ensemble and a slightly stranger, more grown-up vibe.

Why the Stranger Things comparison actually makes sense

This is not a lazy algorithm comparison. The connection is real. Netflix positioned The Boroughs as a supernatural mystery with a misfit crew uncovering a dark secret, and the show also has the Duffer Brothers attached as executive producers. That does not make it a clone, but it does explain why the overlap feels obvious from the start.

The difference is that The Boroughs is not trying to recreate teen-adventure energy beat for beat. The hook here is older, weirder, and a little more off-center. That is actually part of why we like it. It gives the same mystery itch a different texture instead of pretending people only want one flavor of eerie small-town Netflix storytelling.

What viewers are actually saying

• The positive lane is clear: early X chatter keeps circling the same words — creepy, bingeable, and fun to fall into once the mystery gets its claws in.
• The cast angle is landing: Alfred Molina keeps coming up as a reason people are giving the show extra patience and more goodwill right away.
• The honest caveat: not everyone is fully on board. A smaller but real slice of viewers thinks it is too weird or takes a little too long to click.

That mixed reaction does not weaken our recommendation. It sharpens it. This is not for viewers who want the most obvious, broadest, safest Netflix hit. It is for people who like mystery shows that feel a little off in a good way. If that is you, the audience pulse is more encouraging than risky.

Why MyMovieJam recommends it with no sugar coating

The MyMovieJam rule is simple: if we are going to recommend something, it needs a real hook, a clear audience fit, and enough momentum to justify your time. The Boroughs clears that bar. The premise is strong, the crossover appeal is obvious, and the early audience response says the mystery is doing what it needs to do.

We are also not going to fake perfection here. Some viewers will bounce off the oddness. Some will want the show to get to the point faster. Fine. That does not change the bigger call. For the right Netflix viewer, this still looks like an easy recommendation and a smarter bet than another night of random homepage scrolling. That is why it belongs in our single-title review lane and our broader Netflix recommendations hub.

Bottom line

The Boroughs looks like exactly the kind of show that works best when you know what you want: mystery first, ensemble second, eerie tone all the way through. It is not trying to be prestige-serious and it is not trying to be pure comfort television. It is trying to pull you into a weird secret and keep you there. That is enough for us.

The MyMovieJam crew recommends it without reservations for the right audience, and the rating is 8 / 10. If you like Stranger Things, this should be on your Netflix list immediately.

Where to go next if The Boroughs works for you

Quick FAQ